As many of us know, this week is Banned Books Week. Not being someone to react to anything in a knee-jerk fashion, I tend to seek out the opposing view. Or I try to start from a position of assuming that well-intentioned people with the interests of those they love are behind what may seem oppressive or harmful.
The new story below from Erin Murray of KVEO in Brownsville, Texas gives us a pretty middle-of-the-road report on some of the pragmatic thinking behind how and why books are challenged or banned.
Though it's refreshing to learn that there is a process in place and that the number of challenged or banned books has decreased by 2/3 since 2006, it's still alarming that some of the books on the list remain there. And I still suspect that the people -- parents mostly, from what I gather -- are missing the point about the dark power they're attributing to books. That or they're vastly underestimating the intelligence of their children.
Books like the ones that appear on the list, without exception, do nothing more than challenge one's thinking, not corrupt it. If a book elicits a strong response, then all the better. That's what thought is all about.
If anyone should challenge a book, it should be the child who reads it, but for God's sake, don't take it from him before he's had a chance to judge it for himself. As I've said before, you'll KNOW when a book is truly offensive. Those books are out there. But this list? Forget it. You haven't seen offensive yet.
Click here to download PDF containing 2011's list of the challenged and banned books in Texas.
By Erin Murray - KVEO News Center 23 Reporter
Tuesday, September 20, 2011 - 9:15am
SAN JUAN - At the end of every school year, test scores are totaled, grades are given out, and the curriculum is revised. And sometimes, part of those revisions include restricting or banning books completely from school libraries.
In Texas around 70 books from various school levels were challenged and 17 were banned from the shelves. Book banning is a practice used across the state, but over the years it has gone down from almost 50 books banned in 2006 to just 17 this past school year.